How to Make the Ultimate Reestit Mutton Pie

17 January 2018

With Christmas and the New Year behind us and Up Helly Aa to come - as well as just for folk coming in for a tune or a good 'sheeks' - what could be more welcoming or warming than our ultimate reestit mutton pie?

(This piece by Marian Armitage first appeared in Shetland Life magazine.)

In the weeks before Christmas the first stages of our ‘national dish’ begin. The mutton to be 'reestit' will be a fine hog - maybe 18 months or a bit older. The mutton lies in a brine pickle for 2-3 weeks. Next, the meat is hung up to dry, which takes about 4 weeks.

Once you have your piece of reestit mutton which is almost always on the bone - it needs to be covered in cold water and brought to the boil. Lower the heat and allow it to simmer for a good half an hour or so. It is important to taste the water and if it is ‘ower saat’ (too salty) pour off some or all of the water and replace with fresh water. Many folk do this the day before making any dish, so that the fat which rises to the top can be allowed to ‘sturken’ and easily lifted off.


Make some pastry leaves or other decoration with the rest of the scraps - they are too good to waste.

Add the vegetables and mutton and use enough brö (cooking liquid) to keep the filling moist.

Carefully lift on the lid and use water to press it firmly on to the prepared edge. Flake up the edges using a sharp knife and make an attractive fluted edge with your thumb.

Add the pastry decorations and make a hole in the middle to help steam escape.

Beat a small egg and brush all over the top - but not the fluted sides as you want them to rise.

Place near the top on the oven on a baking sheet and give it a good 20 minutes to get the top of the pastry a good golden brown.

Reduce the heat to 150° and give it a further 45-55 minutes. Lay a sheet of baking paper on top if it is browning too much.

Enjoy this fine pie with some lightly cooked Shetland kale or another green vegetable.

For vegetarians (if the pastry you use is vegetarian) - use the same combination of vegetables and add a bayleaf and half milk/water for the brö. Then add cubes of any good crumbly white cheese and cook as above.





Sign up to receive news, updates and special offers.